Unitary plan 'a disgraceful waste'
FALTERING Government plans to abolish Devon's county and district councils have cost the county £8-10 million, business leaders have estimated.
The elections watchdog is investigating whether to replace nine current authorities with either a single unitary council or two – one covering the rural part of the county while Exeter and Exmouth go it alone.
-

The proposed political shake-up has been rumbling on for more than two years and now looks doomed after last week's successful legal challenge over similar plans for Suffolk.
Devon and Cornwall Business Council chairman Tim Jones said "cash and in kind" costs associated with the reorganisation had been put at £8-10 million.
"It is a disgraceful waste of money," he said. "We need every pound we have got to fight through the current climate."
Mr Jones said the "bureaucratic muddle" was "a massive distraction at the wrong time" and argued that senior council executives should have been freed up to concentrate on economic recovery.
"Whitehall seem to decree these things without any regard to the consequences," he went on. "Are they going to pay back all of these expenses? At best, the business community is unimpressed, at worst they say a lot of things ruder than that."
Three district councils in Suffolk last week won their court battle over claims the Boundary Committee failed to consult them over "reservations" about a move to a unitary council which has thrown the committee's plans into disarray.
It had been due to present its final proposals for the future of local government in Devon to Communities Secretary John Denham today.
However, the Department for Communities and Local Government yesterday extended the deadline for the Boundary Committee to provide advice on the proposals for Devon, Norfolk and Suffolk.
"We have today received a request from the Boundary Committee to extend the deadline for their advice which we have granted," said a spokesman. "Once it is clear when any appeal may be determined, a new deadline for the Boundary Committee's advice will be specified.
"We are still clear that if appropriate unitary structures are identified for Devon, Norfolk and Suffolk that have the potential to offer real benefits for the residents of these areas by delivering better services, improved efficiency, stronger strategic leadership and genuine engagement and empowerment of local communities, it would be wrong to deny the people of these three areas those benefits."
The committee said it welcomed the decision "to consider an appropriate date for provision of final advice".
The latest delay could be a fatal blow to Labour's plans to get the reorganisation on the statute book before the next General Election.
If the Government finally admits defeat and ditches the plans, the taxpayer will have to foot the costs which already runs into millions of pounds.
Earlier this month, the Conservatives, which now run Devon County Council, promised to scrap the "reshuffling of town hall deckchairs".








Comments
by Carl, Newton Abbot
Wednesday, July 15 2009, 4:44PM
“Devon County Council have also lost faith - but if you blinked you wouldn't have noticed their hastily delivered and removed comments on their website.
Searching Google for
cache:www.devon.gov.uk/press_boundary_committee_advice_delay_15_july_2009
will show that even they are fed up ... the question is - why was the article from the Devon Leader pulled !
This is what it said at 12:17 on the 15th July
Press Releases
Boundary Committee advice delayed
From Mike Bomford, Exeter 382173, July 15, 2009
The Secretary of State has decided that the Boundary Committee for England is no longer requested to provide advice in relation to the local government review in Devon, which had been expected today, 15 July.
The decision follows a High Court ruling, in relation to the review in Suffolk. For more information visit: www.electoralcommission.org.uk
In response to the decision, the Leader of Devon County Council, Councillor John Hart said:
"Today's news of further delay is entirely predictable given the farce so far.
"The whole process has now descended into chaos and is a distraction that Devon simply does not want or need.
"It's time for the Secretary of State to finally put his ideas for major change in the county into the recycling bin and let us all get on with the job of pulling together, to do our best for local people during the challenging times ahead."
The electoral Commission still don't get it that this is a completely flawed process - whether or not there are savings to be gained, the whole costing process is (using the Devon Leader's word) - a farce - and Devon should know a bit about this !
Council's throughout the county cannot wait any longer and are having to get on with the plans they always had to work/share/partner/save between them - no this route will not be a simple one - infighting/not invented here/hidden agendas - but having Devon CC drive this new ship with its complete lack of pedigree would be a very risky venture - lets get on and draw a line in the sand that we can now all plan from! Money doesn't provide good services and value for money on its own - it need organisations that care and look after the pennies - over the last period, all too many councils have been spending as if money has been going out of fashion, rather than hand over the well earned savings to an organisation (DCC) - that has shown little ability in this area. We need an end to say - "this is how it will look in 3 years - now plan for how we will deliver"
Carl”