City nurse struck off

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Profile image for This is Devon

This is Devon

A NURSE who left a frail dementia patient 'grimacing' in agony after failing to give her any painkillers has been found guilty of a string of blunders and kicked out of the profession.

Michael Callaghan, 66, missed several other patients out of his drug round, including one who relied on treatment to help her breathe.

In two cases he went on to fill in a medicines record to wrongly state they had been administered.

The nurse resigned when a suspicious colleague caught him out by measuring the medication before and after his shift, the Nursing and Midwifery Council heard.

Callaghan denied the omissions while working the night shift at Drake Nursing Home, a Stoke centre treating dementia sufferers, in March 2006.

But the NMC disciplinary panel rejected his claims that whistle-blowing nurse Nichola Strutt was mistaken.

Callaghan had also accused her of having a grudge against him after he criticised her work.

But committee chairman Ruth Adamson praised Mrs Strutt for being a "credible and truthful witness" who had the "best interests of her patients at heart".

Ms Adamson added: "In fact the panel found the registrant's explanation for the source of the grudge wholly unconvincing."

Jan Alan, defending Callaghan, earlier accused Mrs Strutt of "trapping" her colleague.

The lawyer claimed she should have reported her concerns to the then manager and not carried out her own investigation.

The nurse, who now works at a hospital, said she tackled the problem alone because of perceived lack of support from her boss.

Earlier Mrs Strutt said she counted one patient's medication after becoming suspicious she was not receiving the codeine-based painkiller she needed to dull severe nerve pain in her mouth.

She said: "After I got this medication prescribed she was smiling and more relaxed. But she seemed to be in more pain on the mornings after Mr Callaghan had done a night shift. She was grimacing more."

Another patient with severe breathing problems did not receive her Atrovent Nebuliser during the same shift.

Mrs Strutt also used a pen to mark the level on a bottle of liquid laxative which Callaghan was supposed to give to several patients, but it had not gone down the following day.

Callaghan, from Plymouth, denied three charges that he failed to administer drugs and wrongly recorded giving out painkillers and the nebuliser.

The facts were found proved and Callaghan was later kicked out of the profession after a panel found him guilty of misconduct.

Chairman Ruth Adamson said he deliberately did not give out the drugs, causing potential suffering to vulnerable patients who could not communicate their needs.

He then tried to cover his tracks.

The said: "The panel finds the registrant's fitness to practise is impaired by reason of misconduct.

"The three charges involved the deliberate withholding of medicines needed for the proper treatment of patients in his care.

"The withholding of medicines was compounded by false record-keeping, designed to cover up the registrant's wrongdoing.

"He jeopardised the safe care of patients who were denied treatment and possibly caused them unnecessary pain and suffering."

Ms Alan argued the panel should take no further action as the failings were isolated, but Ms Adamson said the case was "far too serious".

Since qualifying in 1965 Irish-born Callaghan has worked at a string of hospitals and care centres.

He retired following the allegations.

6
Tweet this article
Report

6 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Sukie, Mannamead

    Wednesday, October 15 2008, 9:27PM

    “This geezer looks familiar, I think he's a rag and bone man I used to know who was sweet on my old Mum.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Suzannah, Plymouth

    Wednesday, October 15 2008, 9:25PM

    “Angela, you might end up in one yourself one day, if no-one wants to look after you! I think a lot of nurses/carers have a sadistic streak and the profession needs to be monitored more rigorously. On the other side of the coin, the rest are outstanding.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Rambling R, Plymouth

    Wednesday, October 15 2008, 10:13AM

    “In response to Angela and in support of the many hard working, caring and compassionate staff in the "so called care homes". My mother is in a care home not a million miles away from the one mentioned in the article, she has been there for 5 years, though on her admission she was not expected to survive for more than a few weeks. In an ideal world she would have been cared for at home with her family but due to challenging nursing requirements and difficult behaviour brought on by vascular dementia that was not possible. But she has been cared for so well and the staff who work long hours and have to cope with some very distressing situations for very low pay are so caring. I do not think you have the right to tar all nursing homes and their staff with the same brush or try to make people feel guilty if they are unable to care for their relatives at home. I know for sure I would never have been able to offer my mum the level of care 24/7 that she gets in her home from home! Obviously there are going to be some individuals or nursing homes that could do better and they need to be monitored closely especially as they deal with such vunerable individuals, but at least they are monitored which is more than can be said for what can and does go on behind closed doors within families when they are trying to handle situations for which they have no training and with little or no help or respite.
    I would like to end by saying a big THANK YOU to all the care workers who make such a difference to many peoples lives.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Laura, plymouth

    Wednesday, October 15 2008, 10:01AM

    “Michael Callaghan, 66 isn't he a bit old too be a nurse?”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Laura Brown, plymouth

    Wednesday, October 15 2008, 10:01AM

    “Uhhh Michael Callaghan, 66 isn't he a bit old too be a nurse?”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article