Shared ownership homes 'unsellable'

Trusted article source icon
Monday, December 28, 2009
Profile image for This is Cornwall

This is Cornwall

EFFORTS to help people on to the property ladder by allowing them to buy a share in a house are being scuppered by banks refusing to lend to them.

Westcountry councils report homes built for Shared Ownership Schemes have been left empty or rented out, despite growing demand from local people.

Housing waiting lists in the region have more than doubled in the last decade and, despite the recession seeing a drop in property prices, houses still cost up to 16 times the average salary in parts of the region.

The Commission for Rural Communities reported that securing a mortgage for shared ownership schemes was "increasingly difficult, if not impossible". It said that, in the village of Polruan in South East Cornwall, a development of 15 low-cost homes has been achieved "after years of work".

But the shared ownership homes were left "unsellable" because it had been "impossible" for applicants to obtain mortgages.

Similarly, in West Devon, 25 affordable homes due to be sold on Shared Ownership leases had to be converted into social rented units.

Dartmoor National Park Authority built three shared-ownership homes for local people but none of the interested families could get a mortgage.

Privately, council officials claim lenders are "not trying very hard" to support the schemes, instead concentrating on the "easy hits" like buyers with big deposits.

Housing minister John Healey told the Western Morning News: "Although lending is beginning to ease a bit, the demands for large deposits still make homes unaffordable for a lot of people who could afford the mortgage but can't afford the deposit."

He sits alongside city minister Lord Myners of Truro on the Home Finance Forum to "pull together senior people from the major lenders and the consumer groups" to try to get lending moving again. "I think we will see lending become more available but it will recover quite slowly," he said.

The Commission for Rural Communities said: "Development of affordable housing through Shared Ownership properties is proving difficult – driven by both credit constraints for developers and potential buyers.

"These conditions are vital for retaining social housing within rural areas, but at a national level only two or three lenders for this product now exist and it is increasingly difficult, if not impossible, to find a mortgage for homes that are subject to restricted equity in rural areas."

John Packer, affordable housing champion at West Devon Borough Council, said: "This has happened on a lot of our sites. The local people who want shared ownership generally don't have a great deal of money, so they cannot go in with big deposits.

"Of course we are concerned, because our research shows that people do want, if they can, to access shared ownership, but they are finding it more difficult."

In February this year, as the effects of the recession hit the housing industry hard, it was announced that the Rural Housing Trust was to be shut down.

The charity, which worked to build affordable homes in rural areas, said it could not survive the "prevailing difficult trading conditions".

10
Tweet this article
Report

10 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by June, mevagissey

    Wednesday, January 20 2010, 1:39PM

    “4 affordable units in Mevagissey did not sell at £71,000 each! they are now all rented. Developers can build what they want wherever they want, as long as they include the words affordable housing and all with the councils blessing.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Andy Lloyd, Cumbria

    Monday, January 04 2010, 12:57PM

    “Local Authorities in Cumbria are supporting communities that want to deliver affordable housing through Community Land Trusts which offer both rented and part ownership homes. We have found that local building societies are very open to lending on CLT part ownership and require less deposit than some national lenders. Lenders in the UK still see the 'open market' as less risky, and any restricted tenure as 'more risky'. The National Housing Fedration has made the point that UK lenders are excluding themselves from a lucrative sub market. In the past 2.5 x income was the norm and this moderate loan to income ration is more important in long term ability to repay than demanding a large deposit. In America lenders are still happy to lend on Community Land Trust mortgages as they associate them with tiny rates of default.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Gordon, Camborne

    Wednesday, December 30 2009, 12:02AM

    “In 1937 my parents moved to Bath for my father to take up a position as a crane designer at Stothert &Pitts. His salary was £5 per week.The brand new 3 bed semi they chose cost £750.They put down a £100 deposit and the mortage was 85p a week.The builder offered my Father a £5 note or a Gold hunter pocket watch on completion of the purchase,and they took the £5 as it represented a weeks wages. They sold the house for £12,000 in 1977. I visited the house this September this year and the current owner showed me around. Obviously it now has double glazing and an updated kitchen and bathroom, but it is currently valued at £185,000. In my humble opinion the reason for the current stupid price levels is all down to pure greed on behalf of Mortage lenders,estate agents,solicitors, governments and and massive profits by builders,landowners,etc; These unrealistic prices force both parents to work and place the children with day nurserys,child minders etc; thus spawning the current generation of bemused and often troublesome children. There is no substitute for a Mother at home to look after her children and there never will be. Until the whole system reverts to a real attempt to provide genuinely affordable homes,nothing will change.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Gavin, London/Plymouth

    Tuesday, December 29 2009, 8:04PM

    “Shared ownership is a con, its just a scheme to get people to overpay for homes. Mortgage, rent, service charge make these properties extremely costly for a little share. As a key worker I have seen many friends buy them and all have regretted it even those who were happy with till they were trapped in negative equity.

    House prices are set to fall we have a huge housing bubble. Save a deposit for a couple of years and enjoy the price falls.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Peter wARD, West Country

    Tuesday, December 29 2009, 7:03PM

    “Buying a house on a shared ownership business allows estate agents and bankers to easily confuse the buyer and thus rip them off.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article