Lib-Dems face £20 flight levy backlash
LIBERAL Democrats in the Westcountry face a backlash over plans to impose a £20 levy on all domestic flights.
Airlines in the region claim they could be forced to axe routes, which can cut travel times to northern cities or the capital from up to six hours to 60 minutes.
-

Flybe said the "calamitous and naïve" proposals posed a "real threat" to the region's economic recovery.
Lib-Dem leader Nick Clegg insisted the new green tax proposal – which could raise £400 million a year – was needed to send a clear message to people to cut their emissions.
It formed part of his plan to target the wealthiest members of society.
Combined with new green taxes, anti-avoidance measures and cutting relief for high-earners, the Lib-Dems want to lift four million people out of income tax altogether.
Click here to read Matt Chorley's latest blog
The starting threshold for income tax would be raised to £10,000 a year, meaning anybody earning less than that would pay nothing while most people would enjoy a £700 cut.
The introduction of a levy on domestic flights aims to "discourage travellers from choosing air travel over land travel for routes in which the latter is readily available".
It claims it would not "unfairly penalise" people who live in the geographical "extremes of the country" by only applying between destinations where a train ride would take more than six hours.
But Flybe chief commercial officer Mike Rutter accused the Lib-Dem "metropolitan elite" of drawing up "unworkable plans that ignore the world outside the M25".
"Bizarrely, given the number of seats the party currently holds in the Westcountry, this tax would have a direct impact on thousands of their own constituents," he said.
"I'm not a politician, but the idea of slapping an extra £20 on regional aviation seems to be an attack on their own constituents who choose to fly in order to do business or take a well-deserved break.
"A curious case of political self-flagellation, indeed."
The Lib-Dem tax policy document did not include a fixed amount for the levy but Mr Clegg told BBC Radio 4 that it would increase "average price of an airline ticket by £20". Travelling by train, the early morning Newquay to London Paddington service takes five hours and 28 minutes, with two changes. By contrast, a flight from Newquay airport to London City takes one hour, 45 minutes. An Anytime Single rail fare would be £119.50, while a flight currently costs £111. The same ticket on a fast train from Exeter to Manchester costs £90 and takes four hours, 17 minutes while a flight lasts only one hour and five minutes, with a £101.39 price tag.
Mr Clegg said: "Our plans represent the most radical, far-reaching tax reform in a generation.
"They embody everything the Liberal Democrats stand for – fairness, protecting the environment, rewarding hard work. It is right to ask those with the broadest shoulders to bear a little more of the burden so that millions of people on normal earnings get the break they desperately need."









11 Comments
View all
by Jock, Orkney
Thursday, December 03 2009, 10:41AM
“You know the Lib Dems have MPs and MSPs in Orkney and Shetland, Scotland. Up here, residents get 40% off all flights to/from Scottish mainland, and can park for free, as long as they want. Did I mention all their airports are run by the local authorities, and there is no ridiculous £5 charge!
Cornwall Council could learn a lot from these two councils.”
by Steve, PZ
Thursday, December 03 2009, 8:57AM
“We all contributed to the green house gasses. But we didnt all get to profit from it. Why not go after the companies that do not invest in cleaning up their act. And leave my pensioner mum who goes on one trip a year alone.”
by Pasty girl, Cornwall
Thursday, December 03 2009, 8:50AM
“Or they could raise some money by cutting the number of Councillors and MPs and the ridiculous amounts of expenses they can claim. Do we really need so many MPs for Cornwall?”
by Brendan Young, Barnstaple, Bankrupt Britain
Wednesday, December 02 2009, 11:58PM
“What is the point in Britain cutting and taxing its emissions when it only makes up 2% whilst China, India, Russia and America make up more than half alone of all worldwide CO2 emissions!”
by Peter. A., Mullion
Wednesday, December 02 2009, 8:45PM
“Trust the Liberals to come up with this one. Its a good job this party will never form a Government. I travel from Newquay to Manchester a couple of times a year and it winds me up having to pay the current £5 development charge. What they are doing is asking the paying passenger to part fund the airport. But what happens a few years down the line when its grown and making money, the people paying this charge aren't shareholders so will not be enjoying any of the profits.
Over fifty years ago a little patch of land up north was turned into an airport called Ringway. Five local councils owned and ran it. Today it is Englands third airport "Manchester International". The thing is it got there on its own without ripping off passengers. The green Liberals eh, are they the same greens who have been conning the tax payer with their rip off parliamentary expenses scams?? Sod off to Carland Cross and blow on a windmill.
Regards
Peter. A”
by Charles Henry 1945-(diuturnity), Somersetshire
Wednesday, December 02 2009, 8:23PM
“:| Word is, he wants to to surcharge every family with more than 2 cars if they don't become vegetarians. . And he will only wave it if they swear allegiance to Brussels, support the South West Regional Development Agency, and buy a bicycle.”
by james, kernow
Wednesday, December 02 2009, 2:47PM
“Why all the fuss ? It's not like the Fib Dems are ever going to be involved in Government.”
by Colin McNamee, Baltonsborough, Somerset
Wednesday, December 02 2009, 1:27PM
“Clegg will have the Lib Dems back wearing open sandals with patterned socks, longish hair and smoking pipes.
Just hope he continues like this and the electoral pounding predicted for the Lib Dems in the 2010 general election, following on from the Euro elections in June, will be accurate.”
by anon, truro
Wednesday, December 02 2009, 12:19PM
“can some one with something between their ears come on here and tell us without getting on their high horse which is the most polluting per passenger mile , a modern turbo-prop carrying 50 people for 1 hr 40 mins or a diesel loco pulling 3-400 tons of train for 5 hrs carrying 200 people ? I have never actually seen any simple , unbiased figures that allow the public to form an informed opinion.”
by DeludedClegg, Devon
Wednesday, December 02 2009, 11:57AM
“"Lib-Dem leader Nick Clegg insisted the new green tax proposal ¿ which could raise £400 million a year ¿ was needed to send a clear message to people to cut their emissions." - Unfortunately like most politicians old Cleggy is living in lala land. Will it make any difference, no, why? Because theose that can afford to take internal flights now will continue to do so, those that can't will simply take to their cars. Either way pollution with be the result. Don't you braindead politicians realise as much as you want people to stay home and do nothing your wish is simply not reality. Tax people as much as you like it will make no one bit of difference. It will simply create inflation. If you actually focused on the real issue that is that there are simply too many people on the planet, rather than wasting your time with ill-thought out ideas then maybe, just maybe you will actually deal with the 'green' problem.”