Ministers hit out at 'go vegetarian' call

Trusted article source icon
Friday, October 30, 2009
Profile image for This is Cornwall

This is Cornwall

A GOVERNMENT adviser who claimed the public should turn vegetarian to save the planet has been slapped down by ministers.

Lord Stern, author of the influential 2006 Stern Review on tackling global warming, said that meat was a "wasteful" use of water and it created a lot of greenhouse gases, adding "A vegetarian diet is better."

In the Commons yesterday, he came under fire from all sides, with former Labour farming minister Jane Kennedy claiming: "If it is being suggested that vegetarianism will save the world, I am not sure that it is a world in which I want to live."

Shadow Environment Secretary Nick Herbert branded the call for people to give up eating meat as "totally irresponsible and damaging to our livestock industry".

In a sharp rebuke to Lord Stern, farming minister Jim Fitzpatrick told MPs that the comments were "not the position of the Government" and had been slightly exaggerated.

Mr Fitzpatrick insisted: "We support the British agricultural industry – we support our meat producers.

"We certainly believe in a balanced diet. There are a whole number of ways that emissions and greenhouse gases can be tackled and that's not the position of the Government or the department."

He went on: "It is for individual citizens, consumers, to decide what they eat and we support that.

"We say that Lord Stern's comments must be looked at in the perspective of the whole piece he wrote, not one quote, not one sentence."

The National Farmers' Union said Lord Stern's comments suggested "he does not fully understand livestock production" and that an "over-simplified message" does not "take account of the complex interactions within the food and farming system".

Earlier this year, it was announced that meat, eggs and dairy products could be stripped out of some hospital meals under radical plans to cook up "low-carbon food" for patients, visitors and staff.

The eco-measures were aimed at slashing the environmental impact of treating the sick, from the energy used in buildings to the waste produced by disposable medical equipment.

In an interview with the Times this week, Lord Stern claimed that public attitudes would evolve until eating meat was unacceptable.

"I think it's important that people think about what they are doing and that includes what they are eating.

"I am 61 now and attitudes towards drinking and driving have changed radically since I was a student.

"People change their notion of what is responsible. They will increasingly ask about the carbon content of their food."

27
Tweet this article
Report

27 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Jen, Falmouth

    Monday, November 02 2009, 10:37PM

    “It is clear from reading some of these coments that alot of people don't have a clue about livestock farming! I fully accept that meat production is a large contributer in the emmisions thing but there is no way that giving up meat is the answer.
    The agricultural sector needs to educated so that they can reduce their emmissions, but this will not happen over night - they will need to invest in machinery, develop animal and crop genetics and lots more. Perhaps people should reasearch the subject before adopting a meat free lifestyle. The Royal Agricultural Society of England website has some interesting reports that highlight both the carbon bad and carbon friendly aspects of meat production - by SCIENTISTS - not celebs, MP's or media hungry campainers!”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Pasty girl, Redruth

    Monday, November 02 2009, 4:55PM

    “Well it would also help if this stupid Government stopped the eradication of planning laws, that let's farming land be built on. What about those of us who suffer from Irritable Bowel Syndrome? It's impossible for me to live on a vegetarian diet . I have to completely balance what I eat. I don't think it's a mantra John Prescott follows looking at him!”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Sarah, Ashamed to be British sometimes!

    Monday, November 02 2009, 4:18PM

    “Seriously???”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Mike, Truro

    Monday, November 02 2009, 4:05PM

    “Oh my God, Meat Factories. Seriously.? My last bastion in life a decent steak because I can't smoke in public and everything else either gives you heart disease or cancer,,,or both. Leave my meat alone.
    I promise this will never come to fruition. It's just another stupid idea by a stupid politician being supported and given support to by stupid misguided poorly educated people. Keep your hands off my sausage.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Steve, PZ

    Monday, November 02 2009, 1:58PM

    “What about dairy cows. So we dont eat them, we will still need cattle for milk, butter and ice cream. Or are we going to kill off every other animal on the planet so we can fill it up with grass eating people.
    Population control is the only option that would work.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article