Plymouth shopping area has been 'split in two' by store closures
FURTHER high street casualties are forecast as shoppers bypass a "void" that has split Plymouth city centre in two.
As Drake Circus Shopping Centre continues to entice the hordes, traders in Plymouth's West End are predicting a hugely difficult 2012.
-

-

BUSY: Looking up New George Street towards Drake Circus
-

PICTURED LEFT, FROM TOP: Ray Robbins; city centre manager Clint Jones; Dave Moor of Moor & More Beer
-

PICTURED FROM LEFT: Shoppers at the Pannier Market; a boarded up Woolworths, arguably the highest profile high street chainstore to go under; crowds of shoppers outside Drake Circus
-

-

-

Peacocks, Pumpkin Patch and Hawkin's Bazaar are among the national retailers to hit financial difficulties since the year began.
The latter, whose shutters are already up, added to a growing list of empty buildings in lower New George Street, still reeling from the closure of Derry's, Woolworths and TJ Hughes.
That once-bustling area of the city centre now attracts just a third of the shoppers who head to Drake Circus.
Footfall figures for this month show around 60,000 people enter the mall on Saturdays. That compares to around 35,000 in upper New George Street and 18,000 in the West End.
One shop owner, Dave Moor of specialist beer retailer Moor & More Beer, said the Independent Quarter was facing "major problems".
Despite a record-breaking Christmas, he fears it could be "too late" to rescue locally-run shops in Frankfort Gate, where he believes the decline of lower New George Street has seen customer numbers plummet.
Mr Moor said: "This end of town, I'm afraid, has got major problems. The opening of Drake Circus has split this city centre right down Armada Way.
"You step off Armada Way one end and it's full of people; the other, it's silent. You can't believe it's the same city centre.
"We've lost some very big shops that might have attracted people down here – and nothing seems to be happening to address this.
"Most people are struggling on, but we wonder how long we can continue with decreased footfall in this end of the city centre."
There are currently five empty units in Frankfort Gate, two of which are set to be occupied by Plymouth Community Homes.
"You just wonder if this is the beginning of us having problems," Mr Moor added. "I'm beginning to believe it's too late to save some of the businesses down here.
"Times are tough. It looks like we're in for a period of stagnation and why should people start spending their money when things are uncertain?"
However Val Cass, at nearby gift shop Beaux Cadeaux, said she exceeded sales targets over Christmas.
And Ray Robins, City Market Traders' Association chairman, said the nearby Pannier market was 97 per cent full and still attracting interest from would-be stall holders.
"I wouldn't say by any means that trade is fantastic," said Mr Robins, also of Express Goldsmiths.
"But what we are doing is fighting our corner and maintaining our market share. If you come into the Independent Quarter now, you'll find there are very few empty shops."
There are currently 52 vacant retail units in the city centre – 11.3 per cent of the total number.
With the national average sitting somewhere between 11 and 14.3 per cent, Plymouth appears to be outperforming many other cities.
"Plymouth is still a vibrant place to come and shop," said city centre manager Clint Jones. "We are doing reasonably well, but we could be doing better.
"I absolutely believe that we'll see further closures on the high street, but I'm also hopeful that we'll fill some of those vacant premises."
Speaking at a council scrutiny meeting earlier this month, assistant director for economic development David Draffan admitted the area around lower New George Street was "where we have most concerns."
But the former Woolworth's, Derry's and TJ Hughes buildings are now all being actively marketed, Mr Jones confirmed.
He said closures in lower New George Street were primarily a result of national chains hitting the wall.
"It's nothing to do with the actual location," Mr Jones insisted. "It's the companies themselves and the type of retailers that settled there when it was a prime retail area. In many cities you'll find this type of area."
But he added: "It has left us with a big hole [and] if you create a void in the centre of two major shopping areas you're not giving the customers encouragement to move through that space.
"I think that absolutely is a concern for the retailers in the West End of the city. The retail market place at the moment is a very tense place for people to be operating in."
Mr Jones said empty units could become a "living art gallery" for city students. The City Centre Company is asking landlords for permission to use vacant stores for art projects.
West End traders – critical of high rental prices, especially in Frankfort Gate throughout major roadworks last year – praised Plymouth City Council for improving parking in the area. Events at the Big Screen had also helped encourage shoppers into the city, they said.
Cllr Ted Fry, the council's Cabinet member for planning, development and strategic housing, described the city centre as a "comparatively thriving business community".
"Plymouth is open for business and discussions are progressing with significant partners, investors, developers and Government ministers," he added.








9 Comments
by pogle63
Wednesday, February 01 2012, 12:34AM
“It is 2012 the town centre is no longer fit for purpose, the advent of the internet shopping will continue to see high street shops disappear. Online is easy, usually cheaper, no parking charges. I did all of my Christmas shopping on line I went into town for one thing, the shop concerned didn`t have the item, so I ordered it online from their website, what can I say the City centre is doomed in its current form it needs down sizing and redeveloping.”
by superwoman123
Tuesday, January 31 2012, 8:39PM
“i think the bottom of town need to be completely knocked down from the sundail to the market keep the cornwall street side as i love zeuz resturant lol completely revamp it all into another sort of mall / outside cafe,s nice beautiful gardens a lovely big playpark hey maybe put something with ref to our navy army etc into place like a stone ship something to show our great history god let me help design it lol its be for the old young kids familys etc make people want to come back to plymouth please do something as someone said before our plymouth dies”
by GreenGOM
Tuesday, January 31 2012, 7:53PM
“If I was opening a shop in town it would definitely be at the top end. Let's be honest the shops match the clientele and vice versa at the west end. Personally I find I start to itch if I go further down than WH Smith.”
by noxbox
Tuesday, January 31 2012, 7:34PM
“Surely it being winter and you have the choice of staying in a nice warm shopping mall with all the shops and food places you need contained within plus parking attached it's going to win hands down rather than plodding between shops in the cold, wet ,miserable weather whilst parked at a car park that's no where near where you need to be.”
by Tried10
Tuesday, January 31 2012, 4:28PM
“Pumpkin Patch is at the top of town beside Drakes Circus!
Problem is, if you park at Drakes Circus, and can get what you want at the top of town, where is the point in walking all the way to the bottom of town. Its shops arent so nice, seems much more run down and the likelyhood of getting mugged goes up greatly once you go past the sundial!”
by MickBarb
Tuesday, January 31 2012, 4:18PM
“The lower end of New George St was a nice pedestrian area with seats, grassy areas and trees until the council sent in the bulldozers and turned it into what amounts to a car park, with ankle-spraining cobbles to boot.”
by mediclad
Tuesday, January 31 2012, 4:13PM
“Its time to bring in the bulldozers in for the bottom half of the city centre, the shops are either not large enough to accommodate the larger retailer, or too big to attract smaller retailers, this means that the status quo cant continue for long.
What is ideally needed is to build a mall equal in size to Drakes Circus covering the area from Western Approach, Colin Campbell car park to the vacant Woolworths store and unfortunately that would mean either building it around the Market or bull dozing it all together. In an ideal world it would be nice if things could stay the same, but it is quite obvious to everyone that change needs to happen. With a good quality anchor store such as Ikea you would attract more shoppers, visitors and further inward investment for the city.
Im sure there may even be a back hander available for our Tory Leader Viv and a photo opportunity too! Act now before Plymouth dies on its feet!”
by SeepyBee
Tuesday, January 31 2012, 3:57PM
“Get some good shops to open up in the west end and people will come down to shop there. Simples :)”
by Peter20113
Tuesday, January 31 2012, 3:46PM
“Bless Ted Fry, not quite with it”